FISCAL POLICY SPACE FOR DEVELOPING ECONOMIES: A THREE FINANCIAL BALANCE APPROACH IN A STOCK-FLOW CONSISTENT MODEL

Publicado em 26/10/2026 - ISBN: 978-65-272-2867-7

Título do Trabalho
FISCAL POLICY SPACE FOR DEVELOPING ECONOMIES: A THREE FINANCIAL BALANCE APPROACH IN A STOCK-FLOW CONSISTENT MODEL
Autores
  • Emanuella Camargo Mendonça de Mello
  • Wellington Santos De Amorim
  • Leonardo Flauzino de Souza
Modalidade
Resumo Expandido (para Associados AKB) / Extended Abstracts (AKB members)
Área temática
Área 6. Economia Monetária e Financeira e Dinâmica Inflacionária
Data de Publicação
26/10/2026
País da Publicação
Brasil
Idioma da Publicação
pt-BR
Página do Trabalho
https://www.even3.com.br/anais/akb2026-697763/1593140-fiscal-policy-space-for-developing-economies--a-three-financial-balance-approach-in-a-stock-flow-consistent-mode
ISBN
978-65-272-2867-7
Palavras-Chave
Fiscal policy, developing economies, financial balances
Resumo
Introduction The concept of fiscal policy space, which refers to the capacity of governments to increase spending and issue debt, is a subject that is open to interpretation in academic literature. According to Blanchard (2004, 2019), fiscal policy space can increase (or decrease) if inflation and interest rates are very low (or very high). According to Ocampo (2016) and Botta et al. (2023), there is a correlation between fiscal policy space and the balance of payments. It is asserted that an elevated (or reduced) sophisticated production structure, and an increased (or decreased) level of capital controls, can result in an augmentation (or diminution) of fiscal policy space. The first approach utilizes a DSGE (dynamic stochastic general equilibrium) model to assert that the combination of low inflation and low interest rates facilitates governments’ stabilization of future budgets with reduced tax increases, thereby mitigating the associated penalties for society. The second approach utilizes a balance-of-payments constraint model to assert that an increase in the growth rate equilibrium would enhance the likelihood of augmented government spending without exerting pressure on current accounts. We hereby propose a third approach to understanding fiscal policy space in developing economies. This approach utilizes Godley's three financial balance analyses in a stock-flow consistent (SFC) framework within a continuous-time model. The seminal work of Godley & Lavoie (2007), which focused on the developed economies, arrived at a conclusion that aligns with that of Blanchard (2019). Specifically, the former assertive that real interest rates serve as the primary constraints on the fiscal policy space, thereby underscoring the significance of financial considerations in economic policy formulation. However, Godley & Lavoie (2007) are a two financial balance analyses in a SFC framework within a discrete-time model. The primary objective of this study is to extend the analysis proposed by Godley & Lavoie (2007) to cover a three-financial-balance analysis. This expansion involves the incorporation of the current account and external debt constraints within a continuous-time model. The Model The model is built on the following accounting identities: Y=A+G+X-M (1) A+G+X-M=Yp+T_y (2) S_p=Yp-T_y (3) S_g=T_y-G (4) S_x=M-X (5) ?SAV?_p=S_p+iB_p-iD_x+i^* R_p·Ex-T_bp=(B_p ) ?+(R_p ) ?-(D_x ) ? (6) ?SAV?_g=S_g-iB+i^* R+T_b=R ?-B ? (7) ?SAV?_x=S_x+iB_x-i^* R·Ex+iD_x-i^* R_p·Ex-T_bx=(B_x ) ?+(D_x ) ?-R ?-(R_p ) ? (8) Where, Y denotes the total income, A denotes the total private spending, G denotes the total public spending, X denotes the total exports, M denotes the total imports, Yp denotes the private income (aggregation of profits and wages), \operatorname{T}_y denotes the taxes on goods market, S_p denotes the private savings, S_g denotes the public savings, S_x denotes the external savings, {SAV}_p denotes the private financial results, {SAV}_g denotes the pubic financial results, {SAV}_x denotes the external financial results, i denotes the domestic interest rate, i^\ast denotes the international interest rate, B_p denotes the public debt held by private sector, B_x denotes the public debt held by external sector, B denotes the total public debt, D_x denotes the private debt held by external sector, R_p denotes the external assets held by private sector, R denotes the external assets held by public sector, T_{bp} denotes the taxes on financial flows received by private sector, T_{bx} denotes the taxes on financial flows received by external sector, T_b denotes the total taxes on financial flows received, and Ex denotes the exchange rate. The model covers thirty equations and/or sub-equations, which are based on the following main assumptions: exogenous return on physical capital, perfect balance between domestic private debt held by the private sector and physical capital stock, wealth effect on private spending, different conditions on private acquisitions of public debt and external assets or issuing of external debt depending on private financial result, and the combination of total private net worth, total stock of capital, and total public debt. The model also incorporates different taxations on income and financial flows, fiscal rule to build structural primary surplus or structural primary deficit, growth rate of exports and imports defined by Thirlwall (1979) complete equation, domestic prices defined by import share, domestic interest rate defined by covered interest rate parity, and country-risk defined by fiscal and current accounting fundamentals. Preliminary Results The main balance equation, stability conditions, and initial simulation results collectively suggest that: The combination of price elasticities of imports and exports, as well as the income elasticity of imports, is the primary source of instability. Furthermore, an excessively stringent fiscal rule that compels high public savings can result in unsustainable external private indebtedness. Similarly, an excessively lax fiscal rule that forces negative public savings can lead to fiscal and income instability. Finally, the imposition of taxes on financial flows, in combination with public savings, can contribute to the stabilization of the model. References BLANCHARD, Olivier. Fiscal Dominance and Inflation Targeting: Lessons from Brazil. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research, 2004. Disponível em: http://www.nber.org/papers/w10389.pdf. Acesso em: 12 set. 2018. BLANCHARD, Olivier. Public Debt and Low Interest Rates. American Economic Review, [s. l.], v. 109, n. 4, p. 1197–1229, 2019. BOTTA, Alberto et al. Financial integration, productive development and fiscal policy space in developing countries. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, [s. l.], v. 66, p. 175–188, 2023. OCAMPO, José Antonio. Balance of Payments Dominance: Its Implications for Macroeconomic Policy. In: DAMILL, Mario; RAPETTI, Martin; ROZENWURCEL, Guillermo (org.). Macroeconomics and Development: Roberto Frenkel and the Economies of Latin America. New York: Columbia Uhiversity Press, 2016. p. 211–228. THIRLWALL, Anthony Philip. The Balance of Payments Constraint as an Explanation of International Growth Rate Differences. BNL Quarterly Review, [s. l.], v. 32, n. 128, p. 45–53, 1979.
Título do Evento
XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira
Cidade do Evento
São Cristóvão
Título dos Anais do Evento
Anais do XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira
Nome da Editora
Even3
Meio de Divulgação
Meio Digital

Como citar

MELLO, Emanuella Camargo Mendonça de; AMORIM, Wellington Santos De; SOUZA, Leonardo Flauzino de. FISCAL POLICY SPACE FOR DEVELOPING ECONOMIES: A THREE FINANCIAL BALANCE APPROACH IN A STOCK-FLOW CONSISTENT MODEL.. In: Anais do XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira. Anais...Aracaju(SE) Hotel Del Mar, 2026. Disponível em: https//www.even3.com.br/anais/akb2026-697763/1593140-FISCAL-POLICY-SPACE-FOR-DEVELOPING-ECONOMIES--A-THREE-FINANCIAL-BALANCE-APPROACH-IN-A-STOCK-FLOW-CONSISTENT-MODE. Acesso em: 22/11/2026

Trabalho

Even3 Publicacoes