INSTITUTIONALLY SPEAKING: A VEBLENIAN TAKE ON MCCLOSKEY'S THE RHETORIC OF ECONOMICS

Publicado em 26/10/2026 - ISBN: 978-65-272-2867-7

Título do Trabalho
INSTITUTIONALLY SPEAKING: A VEBLENIAN TAKE ON MCCLOSKEY'S THE RHETORIC OF ECONOMICS
Autores
  • Roberto Simiqueli
  • Elizabeth Costa Teixeira
  • Camilly Gabriela Galvão
Modalidade
Artigo (para Associados AKB) / Full papers (AKB members)
Área temática
Área 9. Economia Institucional Original
Data de Publicação
26/10/2026
País da Publicação
Brasil
Idioma da Publicação
pt-BR
Página do Trabalho
https://www.even3.com.br/anais/akb2026-697763/1592934-institutionally-speaking--a-veblenian-take-on-mccloskeys-the-rhetoric-of--economics
ISBN
978-65-272-2867-7
Palavras-Chave
Thorstein Veblen (1857–1929), Deirdre McCloskey (1942–), Original Institutional Economics, Rhetoric of Economics, Economic Methodology.
Resumo
Due to its diverse origins, the multidisciplinary nature of its object of study, and its significant power to influence social dynamics, the treatment of economics as a field of knowledge has long been the focus of debate (Hausman, 2008). The controversy involves not only its definition as a science, but also its scope, its objects of investigation, and, especially, the methodological foundations used in the production of this knowledge. Economics’ conception as a modern science has gained strength with the marginalist revolution. From this movement onward, authors associated with the orthodox tradition began to advocate for an economics closer to the scientific method of the natural and exact sciences, grounded in principles of objectivity, neutrality, deduction, mathematical formalization, and predictive capacity. This positivist view, however, became target for numerous critiques, especially from heterodox traditions that, from Marx to contemporary authors, have questioned the claims of neutrality and universality made by dominant economic theory. In this context, Thorstein Veblen (1857–1929) occupies a central position in the methodological critique of orthodox economics. In Why Is Economics Not an Evolutionary Science? (1898), he argues that the economics of his time was bound to static and descriptive categories that were poorly suited to understanding historical processes of change. This discussion is further developed in The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899), a work in which the author analyzes social dynamics through institutions, habits, and social distinction, without relying on a formal-statistical apparatus. However, his disapproval is not directed at the mere use of data or the empirical description of reality, but rather at the very assumptions of economic theory, especially the hedonistic and rationalistic conception of human nature, which he considered inconsistent with the reality of human behavior and modern business (Veblen, 1909). In view of the aforesaid, the institutionalist critique opens space for a broader discussion: if the assumptions of economic theories are not representative of reality, how do economists construct the authority of their explanations? In The Rhetoric of Economics (1983), Deirdre McCloskey argues that economics would cease progressing if economists depended on the official methodologies and premises they claim to use in order to persuade one another of their ideas. By contrast, the author defends that “economics is literature”, since literary devices such as metaphors, analogies, and stories are frequently used as means of persuasion, sometimes proving to be more effective for this purpose than pure mathematics and statistics. These, in turn, have inherent limitations that metaphors are able to overcome by appealing to common experience. It is essential to emphasize that McCloskey’s critique is not aimed at the use of quantitative methods itself, but at their exploitation as pretentious evidence of neutrality and reliability of results. This remains the case even when such numbers represent little or nothing of reality, or when they allow for multiple interpretations, relations of ambiguity, and limitations that are not explored in subsequent discussions, as scientific rigor would require. By stating that “statistically insignificant number can be very significant for some human purpose” and vice versa, McCloskey (2005) highlights both the role of narrative rhetoric in selecting what truly matters and the presence of an argumentative dimension in the production of economic knowledge. It is interesting to observe that between the two critiques there was considerable progress both in the sophistication of quantitative methods and the quality of available data. The fact that, in this context, a critique of the static nature of orthodoxy remains current may be the strongest point of convergence between the theses of the two authors. On the one hand, McCloskey discusses how economists construct and dispute arguments within the discipline. On the other, Veblenian institutionalism evaluates whether these arguments are capable of interpreting the reality of historical processes and institutional transformations. Although both authors advocate for an economic methodology better suited to its scientific nature, their recommendations follow different paths. McCloskey does not necessarily offer a substantive theory of economic change, proposing only that economics abandon modernism in favor of rhetorical self-awareness and the adoption of a disciplinary conversation based on honesty, clarity, and tolerance. Veblen, in turn, offers a robust alternative for thinking about institutions, habits, and evolution, so that this science may become evolutionary. Although Veblen and McCloskey belong to different periods and traditions, their critiques of economics converge in questioning the scientific and supposedly objective nature of the discipline. Our purpose in this paper is to explore the points of contrast and convergence between these two frameworks. We believe that the Veblenian critique of the utilitarian, teleological, and taxonomic character of orthodoxy constitutes the core of an important epistemological offensive against the modus operandi of the mainstream. Similarly, McCloskey’s effort to make explicit the rhetorical devices indispensable to economic discourse provides a valuable tool for unveiling what is often presented as scientific in the major debates of the field. Notable differences, such as Veblen’s grounding in a theory of social classes and McCloskey’s appeal to economic theory as literature (humanomics), justify a critical confrontation between the two contributions.
Título do Evento
XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira
Cidade do Evento
São Cristóvão
Título dos Anais do Evento
Anais do XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira
Nome da Editora
Even3
Meio de Divulgação
Meio Digital

Como citar

SIMIQUELI, Roberto; TEIXEIRA, Elizabeth Costa; GALVÃO, Camilly Gabriela. INSTITUTIONALLY SPEAKING: A VEBLENIAN TAKE ON MCCLOSKEY'S THE RHETORIC OF ECONOMICS.. In: Anais do XIX Encontro da Associação Keynesiana Brasileira. Anais...Aracaju(SE) Hotel Del Mar, 2026. Disponível em: https//www.even3.com.br/anais/akb2026-697763/1592934-INSTITUTIONALLY-SPEAKING--A-VEBLENIAN-TAKE-ON-MCCLOSKEYS-THE-RHETORIC-OF--ECONOMICS. Acesso em: 22/11/2026

Trabalho

Even3 Publicacoes